
I believe it was the ancient Spartans who first asked the question, "Should we have a small snack before we conquer Aigitida? Or is it best to pillage on an empty stomach? After all, while we want to be at our blood-thirsty best, we also wish to continue shedding fat, as to accentuate our glorious, hard-earned abs." Now, finally, science seems to have answered this ancient quandary. A study out of the University of Birmingham shows that it's a question of what your goals are. From the Associated Press:
In a study published in April, researchers at the University of Birmingham and elsewhere assigned seven people to cycle three days a week, followed by an intense session an hour later without eating. Another seven people followed the same regime, without the instruction to fast.
So, you wanna burn fat, skip the meal. You wanna kick ass, power-up. The AP article goes on to explain how to capitalize on this trick:
Maughan cautioned against doing too much exercise on an empty stomach. "That might help you get very good at burning fat, but you won't be very good at whatever exercise it is you're doing," he said. "Without enough fuel, you won't get the intensity of training you need to get improvements."
With that in mind, if you're eating right, your body should be good for about an hour on glycogen stores before you run out of gas. Any longer than that and you probably need to fuel up with a sugar hit - sometimes like a banana - beforehand.
Of course, the Spartans didn't have bananas. Instead, they dined on figs, barley, wine, cheese and broth. Nothing in there I'd call energy food, unless by "energy," you mean "flatulence," which is technically a form of energy. Yet, with nary an NO supplement or caffeine drink in sight, they managed to be the dominant military land power in ancient Greece for over 275 years, so maybe we all need to spend a little less time worrying about what to eat when and just devote that energy to working hard.
That, and we should all get big, Spartan shields. That won't help our workouts, but we'd look cool.
awesome. i'm pilfering this, spartan style, for my blog too.
ReplyDeleteof course we've been advising this for years but it's always nice to have modern science backing us up what zues always said.
figs, btw, are a great sports food, especially for long hard endeavors like dates, they are very calorically dense and, along with bananas, some of the best natural sports foods around. kind of makes me you want to go run a marathon to warn your friends before me and my crew come pillage your town and take your women, huh?
Really? I would have thought the fiber would have brought them down.
ReplyDeleteExpanding on this further, you might want to check out this Hammer article on pre-race/workout fueling: http://www.hammernutrition.com/knowledge/how-to-properly-fuel-prior-to-workouts-races.1279.html?sect=advanced-knowledge-section
ReplyDeleteEspecially take note of Dr. Misner's timing rationale and exceptions to the 3-hour rule. It's made a HUGE difference in my performance anywhere from 10k to marathon foot races, not to mention distance cycling.
/michm
Thanks for that link, michm. Misner's stuff is always worth a read. I've alterted his schedule somewhat through a lot of trial and error over the years (for myself and Beachbody customers) but I found that his science is better than most people's. He, however, only fuels for endurance events and admits that his theories aren't the standard and to which many more well know professionals adhere. The key to exactly what works for fueling per any individual is personal trail (and unfortunately generally some error).
ReplyDeleteFiber is certainly has its drawbacks for an endurance athlete but figs have a lot of cals per fiber, making them better than most things. Here's some lore:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.foodreference.com/html/figs-nutrition-729.html
Steve,
ReplyDeleteYup, that's where the 3-hour exception for shorter races/workouts comes in. My biggest problem is "intestinal distress" when consuming fuel for endurance sports. Hammers' Steve Born was great in helping me troubleshoot and come up with something that works for me depending on what sport and what distance . . . I've certainly had my share of error!!! UGH!!! For that reason alone, I think I'll stay away from the figs on race days -- ha ha.
/michm
I'm not doubting the nutritional benefits of figs, but I still don't know if they belong in the quick energy camp of bananas.
ReplyDeleteA medium banana is 109 calories, 28g carbs, 1g protein 1g fiber.
3 medium figs are 111 calories, 30g carbs, 0g protein, 6g fiber.
I grant you, pretty much any fruit is sugary enough to be a fine energy boost, but if we get picky about it...